The Trades AlmanacA homeowner's reference for every system in the house

How it works: Electrical

How a circuit breaker trips, and what an AFCI adds

Two trip mechanisms in one switch, and a third that listens for sparks

A gray electrical service panel with its door closed on a basement wall, lit by a flashlight
A gray electrical service panel with its door closed on a basement wall, lit by a flashlight

A circuit breaker is a switch that throws itself. Its job, in CPSC’s words, is to protect the electrical branch-circuit wiring and reduce the risk of fire from overheating of installed wiring due to overloads or faults. It does this with two separate mechanisms inside one small plastic body, each tuned to a different kind of trouble. The arc-fault breaker adds a third.

Two ways to trip

Inside a circuit breaker: contacts held by a latch, a bimetal strip for overloads, an electromagnet for short circuits, and AFCI sensing electronics Line in To the circuit Latch holds the contacts closed Bimetal strip: heats and bends under a sustained overload Electromagnet: throws the latch instantly on a short circuit AFCI electronics: sense the erratic current of dangerous arcing handle Any of the three unlatches the arm, the contacts open, and the handle drops to the tripped position.
Inside a breaker. A bimetal strip bends as it heats under a sustained overload and unlatches the contacts; an electromagnet throws the latch instantly on the huge surge of a short circuit. An AFCI adds electronics that recognize the signature of dangerous arcing.

The thermal trip, for overloads. An overload is the slow kind of trouble: the appliances and lighting on a circuit regularly demand more current than the wiring can safely deliver. Inside the breaker, a bimetal strip heats up when the current exceeds the rating. The strip bends as it warms, and when it bends far enough it unlatches the contacts. CPSC’s technical paper notes that the response depends on the product of the square of the current and the time, which is a precise way of saying a small overload takes a long while to trip and a big one trips fast. A space heater and a hair dryer on the same 15-amp bathroom circuit is the classic thermal trip.

The magnetic trip, for short circuits. A short circuit is current taking a shorter or different path than intended: a hot wire touching neutral or ground, a nail through a cable. The current surges to many times the rating in an instant. The breaker’s magnetic (instantaneous) trip reacts to rapid increases in current of at least 8 to 12 times the rating, throwing the latch before the thermal strip has time to warm.

Both mechanisms exist to protect the copper in the wall, which is why the breaker’s rating is matched to the wire gauge, not to what you want to plug in.

A breaker that keeps tripping

CPSC’s home wiring guide is clear about what repeated trips mean: if a breaker trips whenever a particular switch, light or receptacle is used, obtain help from a qualified electrician, and if fuses continue to blow, keep track of which branch circuits are affected and which appliances are in use when it happens, and consult a qualified electrician to resolve the problem. The one thing never to do is put in a higher-ampere fuse or breaker. CPSC: these overrated devices allow overloading of your branch circuits that can lead to fire. A 20-amp breaker on wire sized for 15 amps turns the breaker from a guard into a bystander.

Resetting one

There are two styles. The first simply moves back to ON. The second, whose tripped handle stops at an intermediate position close to ON, must be moved first to OFF and then to ON. Both types, CPSC says, must be reset by hand after the problem has been eliminated. Reset once. If it trips again on the same load, that is the warning above, not an invitation to try a third time.

Signs of wiring trouble

CPSC’s home wiring guide lists warning signs that may indicate current or future problems, among them lights that dim often, parts of the electrical system that are hot (parts may be warm but should never be hot), and the odor that burned or overheated wires often give off. We would take each to an electrician, and we add one more: a breaker that is warm to the touch.

What an AFCI adds

Conventional breakers respond only to overloads and short circuits. They do not protect against arcing conditions that produce erratic current flow, and arcing is how a lot of electrical fires begin. An arc fault is dangerous sparking from damaged, overheated or stressed wiring or devices: old wires that have become frayed or cracked, a nail or screw driven into a wire behind a wall, a damaged outlet or cord. The current in an arc is often too small or too intermittent for a conventional breaker to trip, yet an arc can be hot enough to ignite nearby combustibles such as wood, paper and carpets.

An arc-fault circuit interrupter uses current-sensing circuitry to discriminate between normal arcing, like the tiny spark when a switch flicks or a motor brushes, and unwanted arcing. Once it detects the unwanted kind, its control circuitry trips the internal contacts and de-energizes the circuit. AFCIs address fire hazards; GFCIs address shock hazards. They are different devices, and one unit can be both: Leviton calls that dual function and says the term “dual” does refer to AFCI and GFCI protection. The word combination is the trap. ESFI uses combination type for an AFCI breaker that provides the same protection as the older branch/feeder type and also detects lower level series arcing in both branch circuits and power cords, and Leviton says the term “combination” does NOT refer to combined AFCI and GFCI protection, so a combination type breaker is still only an AFCI. CPSC’s one-page AFCI publication, though, calls a unit with both AFCI and GFCI protection a combination device.

The National Electrical Code first required AFCI protection in its 1999 edition, for bedroom circuits as of January 1, 2002, according to the National Association of Home Builders. ESFI says that beginning with the 2008 edition the code expanded the requirement beyond bedroom circuits to additional areas of the home, including dining rooms and family rooms, and the home builders’ summary adds kitchens and laundry areas in the 2014 edition. CPSC’s GFCI fact sheet notes that the NEC typically applies only to new construction and major renovations. States, counties and cities decide whether and when to adopt each edition, and the home builders’ state-by-state table shows that some have amended the AFCI rules, so whether a particular room has AFCI protection, and whether it comes from a breaker in the panel or a receptacle in the wall, varies from house to house. For the room lists in the 2020 and 2023 editions, see GFCI and AFCI protection, room by room.

AFCIs get a monthly test, like GFCIs: with the power on, press the TEST button on the breaker, which should trip it; then reset it. If the device does not trip when tested, CPSC says it is defective and should be replaced, and ESFI says to have a licensed electrician do that.

What is yours, and what is an electrician’s

Yours: resetting a tripped breaker once, testing AFCIs monthly, noting which circuit and which loads were involved when something trips, and keeping the panel’s front clear and its door closed between tests. An electrician’s: anything behind the panel cover (CPSC: do not remove the service-panel cover; this is a job for a qualified electrician), a breaker that trips repeatedly, installing or replacing a breaker or a receptacle of any kind, adding or changing AFCI or GFCI protection, and any warm, hot or smelly part of the system. ESFI says AFCIs should only be installed or replaced by a licensed, qualified electrician, and says to contact a licensed electrician to replace one that does not trip when tested. CPSC says to have a qualified electrician install AFCIs and not attempt the work yourself, because the installation involves working within panel boxes that are usually electrically live, even with the main circuit breakers turned off. ESFI also says GFCIs should only be installed by a licensed, qualified electrician. We follow ESFI. GFCI and AFCI protection, room by room sets out where CPSC’s 2010 GFCI fact sheet is looser on receptacles.

References

  1. New Technology for Preventing Residential Electrical Fires: Arc-Fault Circuit Interrupters (AFCIs). U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. https://www.cpsc.gov/s3fs-public/AFCIFireTechnology.pdf
  2. CPSC Guide to Home Wiring Hazards (Publication 518). U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. https://www.cpsc.gov/s3fs-public/518.pdf
  3. Glossary. U.S. Energy Information Administration. https://www.eia.gov/tools/glossary/index.php?id=S
  4. Arc Fault Circuit Interrupter (AFCI) Fact Sheet. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (copy hosted by the City of Brecksville, Ohio). https://www.brecksville.oh.us/DocumentCenter/View/318/AFCI-Fact-Sheet-PDF
  5. Arc-Fault Circuit Interrupters (AFCIs): Prevent Electrical Fires. Electrical Safety Foundation International. https://www.esfi.org/arc-fault-circuit-interrupters-afcis-prevent-electrical-fires/
  6. Preventing Home Fires: Arc Fault Circuit Interrupters (Publication 5133). U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. https://www.cpsc.gov/s3fs-public/5133.pdf
  7. Q and A: Arc Fault Circuit Interrupters. Electrical Safety Foundation International. https://www.esfi.org/q-a-arc-fault-circuit-interrupters/
  8. How to Test an AFCI. Electrical Safety Foundation International. https://www.esfi.org/how-to-test-an-afci/
  9. Dual Function AFCI/GFCI. Leviton. https://leviton.com/products/residential/dual-function-afci-gfci
  10. AFCI and GFCI Requirements: State-by-State Data (revised December 2020). National Association of Home Builders. https://www.nahb.org/-/media/NAHB/advocacy/docs/top-priorities/codes/arcfault-circuit-interrupters/afci-and-gfci-requirements-by-state-dec2020.pdf
  11. GFCIs Fact Sheet (Document 099). U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. https://www.cpsc.gov/s3fs-public/099_0.pdf
  12. Ground Fault Circuit Interrupters (GFCI). Electrical Safety Foundation International. https://www.esfi.org/ground-fault-circuit-interrupters-gfci/

Every fact and number on this page comes from one of the sources above, read during the writing of this page. Codes and standards vary by jurisdiction and edition; your local code and your equipment's manual control.